Abused woman granted refugee status in Hungary

News Stories, 1 November 2005

© UNHCR/L.Taylor
Before receiving refugee status in a landmark gender/domestic violence case, Azita had to resort to smugglers to bring her to safety in Hungary, where strengthened border controls make entry difficult for economic migrants and refugees alike.

BUDAPEST, Hungary, November 1 (UNHCR) Tormented, ostracized, shamed and illiterate Azita may be but her will is unbroken. This is how she made it to Hungary, where she was granted asylum based on the domestic violence and social exclusion she suffered as a woman, and the lack of any protection by the authorities in her home country.

When Azita [not her real name] arrived in Hungary after years of suffering, she did not even know what an asylum procedure was. She was just looking for a safe haven. In considering her claim well-founded and granting her refugee status, the Hungarian asylum authorities have joined the ranks of an increasing number of countries who recognize domestic violence as a form of gender-specific persecution a move welcomed by the UN refugee agency.

"This decision is proof of the flexibility and lasting validity of the refugee definition as contained in Article 1 of the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees," said Lloyd Dakin, UNHCR's representative in Hungary. "We are pleased with the fact that, more and more frequently, gender-related persecution is recognized as falling within the ambit of the 1951 Convention."

Historically, the refugee definition has been interpreted through a framework of predominantly male experiences, which has meant that many claims by women have gone unrecognized.

In the past decade, however, the understanding of sex and gender in the refugee context has advanced substantially a development UNHCR has promoted by providing legal advice and training, as well as by issuing specific guidelines. It is now a generally established legal principle that the refugee definition as a whole should be interpreted with an awareness of gender, and this principle has also been reflected in recent European Union legislation.

According to the 1951 Convention, a refugee is someone who has fled his or her country due to a well-founded fear of persecution because of his or her race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion. Even though gender is not specifically mentioned in the refugee definition, it is widely accepted that it can influence or dictate the type of persecution or harm inflicted, and the reasons for such treatment.

Gender-related claims have been recognized on the basis of many forms of persecution, including acts of sexual violence, domestic violence, forced abortion or sterilization, female genital mutilation, punishment for transgression of social mores, dowry-related violence, forced/early marriage, honour-related crimes and trafficking.

Azita was married off to a man three times her age when she was only 13 before she knew what sexual relations entailed. "I never knew any other form of sex but rape," she says, sitting in the refugee reception centre in the eastern Hungarian city of Debrecen.

The girl became pregnant immediately and, due to her young age, nearly died during childbirth. After more than three months in hospital, she was returned to her husband and the rapes and daily beatings continued. Although the doctors strongly advised against another pregnancy before she was 18, Azita's husband made her pregnant again right away. When she turned 18, she already had three children, with three more to follow.

During her seventh pregnancy, at the age of 25, her husband kicked her so hard that she was severely injured and lost the baby. When it emerged that she would stay barren for the rest of her life, he took all their children away, threw her out of the house, and divorced her.

An even worse predicament awaited Azita: "In my society you are disgraced as a divorced woman," she explains. She was forced to live in the streets, and to work just to get food or a place to sleep indoors for a night or two. "I had uncles in that village, but they could not keep me for more than a few days from time to time, because their wives were against it. While everybody blamed me for abandoning my children, I was sick with longing for them. I would even have endured the beatings again, just to be with my sons and daughters."

Azita carried on living on the margins of society for many years with no protection. A single dream kept her going: to join some of her brothers and sisters who live in Finland.

Finally, she got in touch with people smugglers who promised to bring her there. With help from her siblings, and the little money she herself had managed to save, she left her country. She was under the illusion she would be taken to Finland, but instead her smugglers dumped her alone and helpless in Hungary.

Here, Azita says she went through the asylum procedure without even understanding exactly what it was. She simply relied on her faith in God and the goodness of the people in the Debrecen refugee reception centre.

According to Dr. Agnes Garamvölgyi, Director of Refugee Affairs in the Hungarian Ministry of Interior, "There are many who are recognized on the grounds of belonging to a certain social group. She was granted asylum because she was persecuted, and belongs to a particular social group. We had no doubt about that. However, the case of Azita who became uprooted [in the Middle East] because of domestic violence can indeed be considered as a unique case."

Many countries accept that women, or a narrower sub-group of women, can constitute a particular social group under the 1951 Convention. Yet there are relatively few cases where women who have been subjected to serious violence at the hands of family members have been recognized as refugees. Asylum has nevertheless been granted to survivors of such violence by Argentina, Australia, Canada, Ireland, Romania, Spain, the United Kingdom and now Hungary.

However, not all abused women are automatically entitled to refugee status.

Each case needs to be analysed holistically, and within its own particular cultural and political context. How severe and persistent is the persecution or harm? If the fear of persecution is well-founded, is it related to one or more of the Convention grounds? What protection does the applicant have in law, and in fact? Is the persecution knowingly tolerated by the authorities? Are the authorities unable or unwilling to offer protection? Could the woman find safety somewhere else in her country?

In the case of Azita, she was found to have a well-founded fear of severe and persistent harm because of her status as a divorced woman in a society which offered her no protection.

Azita is unaware of all the sophisticated legal issues and debates about gender-related persecution and refugee status determination. All she wants is to feel safe, and if possible to join her brothers and sisters in Finland.

By Melita H. Sunjic in Budapest, Hungary




UNHCR country pages

How UNHCR Helps Women

By ensuring participation in decision-making and strengthening their self-reliance.

UNHCR's Dialogues with Refugee Women

Progress report on implementation of recommendations.


Women and girls can be especially vulnerable to abuse in mass displacement situations.

Refugee women

Related news stories to Unit plan for ages 15-18 in Civic Education: Refugee women

UNHCR Handbook for the Protection of Women and Girls

This Handbook describes some of the protection challenges faced by women and girls of concern to UNHCR and outlines various strategies to be adopted with partners to tackle these challenges.
First edition, published January 2008

UNHCR policy on refugee women and guidelines on their protection

An assessment of ten years of implementation

Women in Exile

In any displaced population, approximately 50 percent of the uprooted people are women and girls. Stripped of the protection of their homes, their government and sometimes their family structure, females are particularly vulnerable. They face the rigours of long journeys into exile, official harassment or indifference and frequent sexual abuse, even after reaching an apparent place of safety. Women must cope with these threats while being nurse, teacher, breadwinner and physical protector of their families. In the last few years, UNHCR has developed a series of special programmes to ensure women have equal access to protection, basic goods and services as they attempt to rebuild their lives.

On International Women's Day UNHCR highlights, through images from around the world, the difficulties faced by displaced women, along with their strength and resilience.

Women in Exile

Refugee Women

Women and girls make up about 50 percent of the world's refugee population, and they are clearly the most vulnerable. At the same time, it is the women who carry out the crucial tasks in refugee camps – caring for their children, participating in self-development projects, and keeping their uprooted families together.

To honour them and to draw attention to their plight, the High Commissioner for Refugees decided to dedicate World Refugee Day on June 20, 2002, to women refugees.

The photographs in this gallery show some of the many roles uprooted women play around the world. They vividly portray a wide range of emotions, from the determination of Macedonian mothers taking their children home from Kosovo and the hope of Sierra Leonean girls in a Guinean camp, to the tears of joy from two reunited sisters. Most importantly, they bring to life the tremendous human dignity and courage of women refugees even in the most difficult of circumstances.

Refugee Women

Statelessness and Women

Statelessness can arise when citizenship laws do not treat men and women equally. Statelessness bars people from rights that most people take for granted such as getting a job, buying a house, travelling, opening a bank account, getting an education, accessing health care. It can even lead to detention.

In some countries, nationality laws do not allow mothers to confer nationality to their children on an equal basis as fathers and this creates the risk that these children will be left stateless. In others, women cannot acquire, change or retain their nationality on an equal basis as men. More than 40 countries still discriminate against women with respect to these elements.

Fortunately, there is a growing trend for states to remedy gender discrimination in their nationality laws, as a result of developments in international human rights law and helped by vigorous advocacy from women's rights groups. The women and children depicted here have faced problems over nationality.

Statelessness and Women

Hungary: Beginning to HelpPlay video

Hungary: Beginning to Help

Refugees and migrants continue to arrive from Serbia into Hungary in by the thousands. But now, thanks to requests from the Hungarian government,UNHCR is helping in bringing order and more speed to dealing with the newcomers.
Hungary: Stranded in BudapestPlay video

Hungary: Stranded in Budapest

Outside the Keleti train station in Budapest, over 3,000 refugees wait to continue their journey. For two days now, they have been stuck here after Hungarian authorities closed off the station, preventing all refugees from taking trains bound for Austria and Germany.
2015 World Day against Trafficking in Persons: ICAT Video StatementPlay video

2015 World Day against Trafficking in Persons: ICAT Video Statement

The second annual World Day against Trafficking in Persons is being marked on 30 July 2015. To mark this special day, the Principals of eight of the world's key organizations working to tackle this crime have come together to issue a special statement. Together, these eight heads of organizations are urging more to be done to help the millions of women, men and children who fall victim to one of today's most brutal crimes, and to join forces to improve trafficked persons' access to remedies that respond to their individual needs. This video includes statements from the following members of the Inter-Agency Coordination Group against Trafficking in Persons (ICAT): ILO, INTERPOL, IOM, OHCHR, UN Women, UNHCR, UNICRI and UNODC.