Roma head for Sweden to escape extreme poverty, alleged discrimination in Hungary

News Stories, 12 December 2006

© MTI Hungary
Hungarian Roma asylum seekers in front of a refugee reception centre in Malmö, Sweden.

MOHACS, Hungary, December 12 (UNHCR) Members of Hungary's Roma community have been seeking asylum in Sweden in unprecedented numbers in recent months, pleading extreme poverty and alleging labour and education discrimination back home.

The number of arrivals rose dramatically after a first batch of 20 Hungarian Roma from Mohacs flew to Malmö in Sweden on a budget flight last summer they did not need visas because both countries are members of the European Union (EU). When glowing reports about Sweden's economy and welfare state started reaching Hungary, scores more soon followed.

Between January and November this year, 356 Hungarian citizens had applied for asylum in Sweden, according to Swedish figures. Some 336 of them had arrived since mid-October and most, if not all, were believed to be Roma. "Some families sold all their belongings, including television sets and furniture, to be able to buy the air ticket to Malmö," said Istvan Kovacs, a Roma community leader here.

But Sweden was having none of it and has to date rejected 101 of the applications, while another 87 applicants withdrew their asylum claims. Some have been deported, but numbers are not available. Swedish diplomats were sent to Mohacs and other southern Hungarian towns in late November to ask Roma leaders to discourage members of their communities from seeking asylum in Sweden.

The envoys explained that Sweden and other EU states are bound by treaty not to give refugee status to each other's citizens a position UNHCR disagrees with. "It is the issue of persecution and discrimination that decides whether someone is a refugee, not the citizenship of the country of origin," said UNHCR Deputy Regional Representative Michael Lindenbauer.

But the Roma say they are acting out of desperation, arguing that they face difficulties in getting jobs and a decent education in Hungary, which is suffering a serious public deficit level two years after joining the EU and faces tough austerity measures. They also say Sweden's tough stance will not deter others in Hungary from seeking asylum overseas.

"Only the most destitute go abroad," said Sandor Csonka, a leader of the Lungo Drom Roma Association in Mohacs, adding that even those earning the minimum wage of 39,000 forints (US$200) a month would not risk leaving their jobs. "The ones leaving are running away from total despair, total destitution."

Katalin, a 27-year-old married mother of two, was among those rejected and sent back from Sweden to Hungary late last month. "We were told that we are not refugees as there is no persecution in Hungary. I wonder if it will amount to persecution if my [two] children will go to bed hungry every day in a cold apartment that we cannot afford to heat."

She said it was very difficult to find jobs in the south, and alleged that other employers discriminated against the Roma when looking to hire people. Csonka and other Roma point also to discrimination in education their charges are backed up in government commissioned reports.

"We were returned from Sweden, but we will go elsewhere to look for a better life as soon as we can," said Katalin, whose family barely scrapes by on social security payments worth under US$3 per person.

UNHCR, however, encourages local solutions. "We are aware that Roma are discriminated against and face a whole range of serious problems, not only in Hungary but also in many other Central and Eastern European countries", said Lloyd Dakin, UNHCR's Budapest-based regional representative. "But the problems that the Roma face should be tackled within the countries of origin."

The Hungarian government announced measures in November aimed at stemming the outflow, including the allocation of US$1.5 million for job creation schemes in the southern areas where most Roma live. But József Szekó, mayor of Mohacs, said this would only be enough to employ 300 people for one year, adding that there were 3,000 Roma in his town alone.

At a forum here in late November for Roma asylum seekers sent back from Sweden, a Ministry of Social Affairs and Labour official said the government realised that the Roma in Hungary faced "a grave situation" finding employment, as well as intolerance and discrimination in the workplace. He said a state-sponsored public service labour scheme could be a solution, while adding that there was not money to provide jobs for everyone.

The Lungo Drom Roma Association's Csonka, meanwhile, said the current situation reminded him of the exodus of thousands of Roma asylum seekers, predominantly to Canada, in the 1990s. "The austerity measures introduced by the government come down most heavily on the Roma," he said.

"A decade ago when thousands of Roma went to Canada for asylum, their reasons were similar. Roma then also fled from Hungary simply because they had nothing to eat," Csonka added. The influx ended when Canada started demanding visas for Hungarians, something Sweden cannot do.

By Andrea Szobolits in Mohacs, Hungary




UNHCR country pages

Civil Registration and the Prevention of Statelessness: A Survey of Roma, Ashkaelia and Egyptians (RAE) in Montenegro

Results of a study carried out in 2008 by UNHCR, with support from the European Commission and UNICEF, May 2009.

Looking Back: When Hungary's Borders with Austria Opened for East Germans

It's not often that a single sentence can send a photographer rushing into action, but Hungarian photographer Barnabas Szabo did not have to hear more than that of then-Hungarian Foreign Minister Guyla Horn's televised announcement 25 years ago - September 10, 1989 - that at midnight Hungary would open its border with Austria and let East German refugees leave the country. "After the very first sentence I jumped up, took my camera, ran to my old Trabant and set off for the border," he recalled. The effect of Hungary's momentous decision was freedom for tens of thousands of East Germans who had been streaming into Hungary since May. At first they found refuge in the West German embassy, but as numbers grew, refugee camps were set up in Budapest and on the shores of Lake Balaton. The collapse of the Berlin Wall followed less than two months later. Communism was swept from Eastern Europe by the end of 1989. Another Hungarian photographer, Tamas Szigeti, who visited the abandoned refugee camp at Csilleberc the following day, recorded the haste in which people departed, leaving clothes, toys and even half-cooked dinners. No matter how uncertain the new life beckoning to them, the East Germans were clearly ready to leave fear and the Communist dictatorship behind forever.

Looking Back: When Hungary's Borders with Austria Opened for East Germans

Mahmoud's Journey: A Young Syrian Survives Being Shot At, Detained and Bullied to Find a New Life in Sweden

A photo essay by Shawn Baldwin and Johan Bävman

A photograph of Syrian refugee, Mahmoud, shows the nine-year-old looking wistfully out of the window of an apartment block in the Egyptian capital, Cairo. Perhaps he is thinking of happier days at school in his home town of Aleppo or maybe he is wondering what life will be like when he and his family are resettled in Sweden. When the image was taken late last year, Mahmoud had not been able to attend school for two years. His family had fled Syria in October 2012. Like 300,000 other Syrians, they sought shelter in Egypt, where life was tough - and became tougher in 2013, when public opinion began to turn against the Syrians as Egypt struggled with its own problems. Mahmoud became the target of bullies, even at one point being physically attacked. Afterwards, he refused to leave the rented family apartment in 6th of October City, a drab, sand-swept satellite suburb of Cairo.

Mahmoud's father tried to send him to Italy on a smuggler's boat, but the vessel was fired on and the traumatized boy ended up spending five days in a local detention centre. Once back home, he fell target to the bullying once more. But his case came to the attention of UNHCR and the refugee agency recommended Mahmoud and his family for resettlement. In January 2014, Mahmoud and his family flew to Sweden to begin a new life in the small town of Torsby, where he runs and plays outside without fear - he even had his first snowball fight. And now he is back at school.

Mahmoud's Journey: A Young Syrian Survives Being Shot At, Detained and Bullied to Find a New Life in Sweden

Hungarian Crisis - 50th Anniversary

The spontaneous Hungarian uprising began on 23 October 1956. Two weeks later, the revolution was crushed by a Soviet military intervention, and by early 1957, 200,000 people had fled as refugees - 180,000 to Austria and 20,000 to Yugoslavia.

Hundreds of volunteers worked alongside international and local aid organizations to provide shelter and food, as the Austrians and the international community provided the refugees with an unprecedented level of support.

UNHCR was made 'Lead Agency' and, along with the Red Cross and ICEM, helped coordinate protection, assistance and a quite extraordinary resettlement programme.

Within two years, more than 180,000 Hungarians were resettled to 37 countries spanning five continents. The US, Canada, the UK, West Germany, Australia, Switzerland, France, Sweden and Belgium each accepted more than 5,000 refugees. Italy, the Netherlands, Israel, Brazil, Norway, Denmark, South Africa, New Zealand and Argentina all took over 1,000. The rest were spread around a further 19 countries ranging from the Dominican Republic to Turkey. Some Hungarians were integrated in Austria (8,000) and Yugoslavia (700), while 11,000 returned home voluntarily.

More in Refugees Magazine Issue N° 144: Where Are They Now? The Hungarian Refugees, 50 Years On (published October 2006) here

Hungarian Crisis - 50th Anniversary

Hungary: Beginning to HelpPlay video

Hungary: Beginning to Help

Refugees and migrants continue to arrive from Serbia into Hungary in by the thousands. But now, thanks to requests from the Hungarian government,UNHCR is helping in bringing order and more speed to dealing with the newcomers.
Hungary: Stranded in BudapestPlay video

Hungary: Stranded in Budapest

Outside the Keleti train station in Budapest, over 3,000 refugees wait to continue their journey. For two days now, they have been stuck here after Hungarian authorities closed off the station, preventing all refugees from taking trains bound for Austria and Germany.
Sweden: Mahmoud's EscapePlay video

Sweden: Mahmoud's Escape

Mahmoud was one of more than 300,000 Syrian refugees who have sought safety in Egypt since the conflict in his homeland began three years ago. The nine-year-old was so desperate to attend school that he risked his life to get to Europe. He was stopped and sent back to Egypt but is now making a fresh start in Sweden.