Q&A: Maltese lawyer stands up for boatpeople

News Stories, 21 September 2007

© UNHCR/A.Pace
Katrine Camilleri, lawyer and 2007 Nansen Refugee Award winner.

GENEVA, September 21 (UNHCR) Lawyer Katrine Camilleri was named earlier this week as winner of the 2007 Nansen Refugee Award for her courageous work defending the rights of refugees and migrants in Malta. She first became interested in the plight of refugees in the mid-1990s, before joining the Jesuit Refugee Services (JRS) and eventually working full-time on the issue. With a rise in the number of asylum seekers, irregular migration has become a controversial issue in Malta and many people resent her work. Camilleri spoke recently with UNHCR Senior Media Officer William Spindler. Excerpts from the interview:

Tell us about a typical working day in your life

My days are all different; that is one of the nice things about my work. Apart from working on cases, I have to do things like administration and project management. I see people who come to us because they need legal assistance. Most of our work is focused on detention centres; we offer legal assistance and basic information to those in detention.

We have a project with UNHCR aimed at preventing and responding to sexual and gender-based violence among those in detention. We also provide social work and provide psychological support and assistance, depending on people's needs.

What is the most difficult part of your job?

Without doubt, working in an environment of detention. People are deprived of their liberty and that is very hard. They are often held in very difficult conditions. They have not committed any crime, so there is a sense of injustice. They arrive in Malta by boat, and the first thing they know of in Malta is that they are put in a detention centre. This is really a very difficult environment to work in.

When we talk about their rights with them, we often face suspicion. It is difficult to gain the trust of people deprived of their freedom. They have never lived in Malta, they know only the detention centre. Sometimes we watch how people just crumble in front of you and this has a deep impact on our work. This affects how they relate to us. You see people suffering and you have no miracle solution to offer to them.

In addition, you often have to advocate for people who are not trusted [by the public] and portrayed in a negative light [by the media]. This is difficult. You are defending people who are unpopular, and the population is often hostile to them. People are not sympathetic.

Why are Maltese people hostile to boat people?

You do find people who are sympathetic but, in general, Maltese are afraid. Malta is very small and we are acutely aware of how limited our resources are. People feel that there is barely enough for us and now we have to deal with what is perceived as a mass influx of people who are so different from how Maltese perceive themselves. There is some prejudice. I am not saying that all Maltese are bigoted or racist, they are not, but there is a sense of fear.

Some of this hostility was directed at you. Can you tell us about it?

My car and the door of my house were set on fire. The motivation for these attacks was never stated. There were other attacks against the Jesuit community at the same time. Houses of journalists were also targeted. In that context, it was assumed that the attacks were a result of our stand in favour of human rights, refugees' rights, respect for other people and tolerance.

Are there any positive stories that have inspired you?

Every time we make a difference to an individual's life, that is something that always encourages us to continue, in spite of the fact that the bigger picture does not change that easily. When you can see the change that you have made, that is extremely encouraging.

Asylum seekers themselves are inspiring; their support, their courage and their hope encourages us to continue to work in very difficult circumstances. I have come across individual asylum seekers who inspired me because of their commitment, because they themselves had fought for what they believed in. They were inspiring individuals.

I am also part of a team that is really committed to working for the people we serve. In a big or small way we all make a difference at the end of the day, and that is the most important thing.

What happens to boat people when they land in Malta?

Most people are rescued at sea; there are incidents when only a small number of people survive. There are also people who land directly in Malta. Whether they are brought in or they land here, they are taken to register with the immigration police. There is a brief security check-up and people who need medical treatment are referred to a hospital. After registration, they are transferred to a detention centre.

People who are obviously vulnerable, such as pregnant women, families with small children or people whose disability is obvious are immediately referred by the immigration authorities to a government agency. This body [the Organization for the Integration and Welfare of Asylum Seekers], assesses whether they should be released or not. Until this is done, people are kept in detention.

Detention centres hold a mixture of people. The majority are young men who arrive in Malta alone, but there are also women and children. They are all detained together, with hardly any supervision. In one centre, single men, women and families with children are all kept in the same centre. There is no separate accommodation for men and women. Everyone is detained together. Facilities are far from ideal: toilets, showers, they are all shared. There are not even locks on the doors.

Vulnerable immigrants can spend two or three weeks or even longer, at times months, in detention. It is difficult for adults, let alone children, to be allowed in the open air only two or three times a week. Imagine being locked with small children and even newborn babies in a centre which is only a corridor with lots of dormitories.

The authorities deny that this is a form of deterrence. If that is the intention, it will not work because very few people want to come to Malta. It is not what they find here, but what they are leaving behind that pushes them to move on.

The official reason is that there is a lack of resources, but it would not take much to improve conditions. There are often not enough clothes, shoes, furniture only bunk beds, not chairs. It would be possible to make small changes which could make a substantial improvement and would not require massive resources; separate sanitary facilities, adequate respect for privacy and so on.

Should Malta be getting more help and support in shouldering the burden?

Malta has obvious limitations, maybe more than many other countries. There is an unfortunate tendency in Europe to push the issue of immigrants to the border states, which are the least equipped and experienced in dealing with this problem.

The Maltese government and those of other new member states of the EU [European Union] need support as they are the border states of the EU. There should be a more equitable way of sharing responsibilities. The Maltese government has responsibilities, but so do other governments.




UNHCR country pages

The Nansen Refugee Award

The Nansen Refugee Award

Given to individuals or organizations for outstanding service in the cause of refugees.

2008 Nansen Refugee Award

The UN refugee agency has named the British coordinator of a UN-run mine clearance programme in southern Lebanon and his civilian staff, including almost 1,000 Lebanese mine clearers, as the winners of the 2008 Nansen Refugee Award.

Christopher Clark, a former officer with the British armed forces, became manager of the UN Mine Action Coordination Centre-South Lebanon (UNMACC-SL) n 2003. His teams have detected and destroyed tons of unexploded ordnance (UXO) and tens of thousands of mines. This includes almost 145,000 submunitions (bomblets from cluster-bombs) found in southern Lebanon since the five-week war of mid-2006.

Their work helped enable the return home of almost 1 million Lebanese uprooted by the conflict. But there has been a cost – 13 mine clearers have been killed, while a further 38 have suffered cluster-bomb injuries since 2006. Southern Lebanon is once more thriving with life and industry, while the process of reconstruction continues apace thanks, in large part, to the work of the 2008 Nansen Award winners.

2008 Nansen Refugee Award

2007 Nansen Refugee Award

The UN refugee agency's Nansen Awards Committee has named Dr. Katrine Camilleri, a 37-year-old lawyer with the Jesuit Refugee Service (JRS) in Malta, as the winner of the 2007 Nansen Refugee Award. The Committee was impressed by the political and civic courage she has shown in dealing with the refugee situation in Malta.

Dr. Camilleri first became aware of the plight of refugees as a 16-year-old girl when a priest visited her school to talk about his work. After graduating from the University of Malta in 1994, she began working in a small law firm where she came into contact with refugees. As Dr. Camilleri's interest grew in this humanitarian field, she started to work with the JRS office in Malta in 1997.

Over the last year, JRS and Dr. Camilleri have faced a series of attacks. Nine vehicles belonging to the Jesuits were burned in two separate attacks. And this April, arsonists set fire to both Dr. Camilleri's car and her front door, terrifying her family. The perpetrators were never caught but the attacks shocked Maltese society and drew condemnation from the Government of Malta. Dr. Camilleri continues to lead the JRS Malta legal team as Assistant Director.

2007 Nansen Refugee Award

The Nansen Refugee Award 2005

Burundian humanitarian worker Maggy Barankitse received the 2005 Nansen Refugee Award for her tireless work on behalf of children affected by war, poverty and disease. The Nansen medal was presented at a grand ceremony in Brussels by H.R.H. Princess Mathilde of Belgium and UN Deputy High Commissioner for Refugees Wendy Chamberlin.

Accepting the award, Barankitse said her work was inspired by one single goal: peace. "Accept your fellow man, sit down together, make this world a world of brothers and sisters," she said. "Nothing resists love, that's the message that I want to spread."

Sponsored by UNHCR corporate partner Microsoft, the ceremony and reception at Concert Noble was also attended by Belgium's Minister for Development Co-operation Armand De Decker, European Commissioner for Development and Humanitarian Aid Louis Michel, renowned Burundian singer Khadja Nin, Congolese refugee and comedian Pie Tshibanda, and French singer and UNHCR Goodwill Ambassador Julien Clerc. Among others.

The Nansen Refugee Award 2005

Nansen Refugee Award: Pope Francis meets Sister AngéliquePlay video

Nansen Refugee Award: Pope Francis meets Sister Angélique

Pope Francis meets and blesses UNHCR's 2013 Nansen Refugee Award winner Sister Angélique Namaika in St Peter's Square, Vatican City.
Nansen Refugee Award: The Global Refugee CrisisPlay video

Nansen Refugee Award: The Global Refugee Crisis

At the 2013 UNHCR Nansen Refugee Award ceremony a moment was taken to reflect on the endless refugee plight.
Nansen Refugee Award: Past WinnersPlay video

Nansen Refugee Award: Past Winners

At the 2013 UNHCR Nansen Refugee Award ceremony a moment was taken to remember past Nansen Refugee Award laureates.