Zimbabweans face uphill struggle in search for asylum in South Africa

News Stories, 11 July 2008

© UNHCR/J.Oatway
Through the Wire: At Musina on the South African border with Zimbabwe.

MUSINA, South Africa, July 11 (UNHCR) The UN refugee agency said on Friday it was concerned that people fleeing political violence in Zimbabwe were not being properly screened at the South Africa border, raising fears that people with a genuine fear of persecution could be deported.

The number of Zimbabweans fleeing to South Africa has risen considerably and so have their deportations since the holding of general and presidential elections in March. A subsequent crackdown on opposition supporters around Zimbabwe exacerbated the situation, which has further worsened since the presidential run-off in late June.

In the last 40 days alone, South Africa has sent back some 17,000 Zimbabweans through the Beit Bridge border post, despite earlier calls from UNHCR to suspend all deportations.

UNHCR, refugee advocacy groups and rights organizations say Zimbabweans who come to South Africa face an uphill struggle in their bid to obtain asylum. "The government should do more to help them, in line with its international legal commitments," said Sanda Kimbimbi, UNHCR's regional representative.

Of the 35,000 Zimbabweans who applied for asylum in South Africa in 2006 and 2007, only 500 were granted refugee status, according to official figures.

A further indication of the evolving refugee situation is the growing crowd of Zimbabweans around 3,000-4,000 approaching the Crown Mines Refugee Registration Office in Johannesburg each Thursday and Friday, the days set aside for Zimbabwean asylum seekers.

UNHCR has strengthened its presence at the border and its protection officers are making daily visits to a detention centre in Musina to identify Zimbabwean asylum seekers and refer them to the appropriate authorities.

"There are so many people who are deported on a daily basis, we are simply unable to interview 95 percent of them," said Camilla Kragelund, head of the UNHCR office in Musina. "The only Zimbabweans who are getting asylum are those who come into contact with UNHCR or our partners," she added.

Aid workers in the border towns are beginning to see a shift in the dynamics of Zimbabwean displacement. Whereas 90 percent of those crossing into South Africa in the past were young single men seeking a better economic future, increasingly the new arrivals consist of families fleeing political violence.

"The trend is changing, we are getting entire family units, many with physical injuries, seeking asylum," said Thandi Hadebe, head of the Jesuit Refugee Service's office in the town of Makhado (Louis Trichardt), south of the border. Since the start of June, the office has helped some 300-400 Zimbabweans a day.

In Musina, there is a visible presence of Zimbabweans in distressed circumstances. "There are many people in desperate need of assistance. Some arrive after days on the road, exhausted and famished," said Father Adrian McHugh, whose church provides food to new arrivals.

At the Roman Catholic Church in Nancefield, a neighbourhood of Musina, mothers and their children queue for food parcels. Many of the Zimbabweans have terrible stories to tell. "They speak of killings and beatings; they have brutal injuries, bruises, swollen legs and feet," said Debra Sibanda, a church worker.

The majority of Zimbabweans are entering South Africa through unauthorized border points. They have to evade security patrols and police checkpoints; fend off criminal gangs operating on the border, navigate the crocodile and hippo-infested Limpopo River; and cross barbed wire fences. Those who complete the journey remain fearful of arrest and deportation, and many go underground, making them vulnerable to rape and robbery.

In Campbell, a township near Musina, UNHCR teams met a mixed group of recently arrived Zimbabweans, many of them sleeping rough in the bush, with only a blanket or two to protect them from the cold winter weather. Many were students, such as Prosper, who took part in anti-government protests.

Police responded by harassing suspected ringleaders and opposition sympathizers. The student showed off deep cuts on his head and marks on his body that he alleged were inflicted by Zimbabwean police. "Things were getting tight and politically motivated attacks became the norm," he said.

Feeling threatened, he decided to flee to South Africa in late April with three other students. "We arrived at the border at night. We walked through the bush and crossed through the Limpopo River. It was risky and one of the students who was with us ... drowned." They were also robbed by bandits.

Meanwhile, High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres has reiterated his call on South Africa to halt all deportations of Zimbabweans and ensure that those seeking asylum have access to national asylum procedures. UNHCR also urges South Africa to exceptionally grant Zimbabweans a temporary legal status allowing them to stay in the country, an option which is foreseen in national legislation.

There are presently more than 138,000 registered refugees and asylum seekers in South Africa, coming from a wide range of countries. Zimbabweans have also sought refuge in other countries.

By Yusuf Hassan in Musina, South Africa




UNHCR country pages


UNHCR advocates fair and efficient procedures for asylum-seekers

Zero-Star "Hotel" that Asylum-Seekers Call Home in Dijon

France is one of the main destinations for asylum-seekers in Europe, with some 55,000 new asylum applications in 2012. As a result of the growing number of applicants, many French cities are facing an acute shortage of accommodation for asylum-seekers.

The government is trying to address the problem and, in February 2013, announced the creation of 4,000 additional places in state-run reception centres for asylum-seekers. But many asylum-seekers are still forced to sleep rough or to occupy empty buildings. One such building, dubbed the "Refugee Hotel" by its transient population, lies on the outskirts of the eastern city of Dijon. It illustrates the critical accommodation situation.

The former meat-packing plant is home to about 100 asylum-seekers, mostly from Chad, Mali and Somalia, but also from Georgia, Kosovo and other Eastern European countries. Most are single men, but there are also two families.

In this dank, rat-infested empty building, the pipes leak and the electricity supply is sporadic. There is only one lavatory, two taps with running water, no bathing facilities and no kitchen. The asylum-seekers sleep in the former cold-storage rooms. The authorities have tried to close the squat several times. These images, taken by British photographer Jason Tanner, show the desperate state of the building and depict the people who call it home.

Zero-Star "Hotel" that Asylum-Seekers Call Home in Dijon

South Africa's Invisible People

In March 2011, UNHCR initiated a project with the South African non-governmental organization, Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR), to tackle the issue of statelessness. The specific goals of the project were to provide direct legal services to stateless people and those at risk of statelessness; to engage government on the need for legal reform to prevent and reduce statelessness; to raise awareness about stateless people and their rights; and to advocate for the ratification of the 1954 and 1961 UN conventions on statelessness.

LHR had conceived the project a year earlier after noticing that large numbers of Zimbabwean-born asylum-seekers were telling its staff that they faced problems getting jobs, studying or setting up businesses - all allowed under South African law. They told LHR that when they applied for Zimbabwean passports, necessary to access these rights, they were informed by consular officials that they were no longer recognized as Zimbabwean citizens. This effectively made them stateless.

Since the project's inception, LHR has reached more than 2,000 people who are stateless or at risk of statelessness. These people came from more than 20 different countries. It has identified numerous categories of concern in South Africa, both migrants and those born in the country.

The following photo set portrays some of the people who have been, or are being, helped by the project. The portraits were taken by photographer Daniel Boshoff. Some of the subjects asked that their names be changed.

South Africa's Invisible People

South Africa: Searching for Coexistence

South Africa is one of the few countries in Africa where registered refugees and asylum-seekers can legally move about freely, access social services and compete with locals for jobs.

But while these right are enshrined in law, in practice they are sometimes ignored and refugees and asylum-seekers often find themselves turned away by employers or competing with the poorest locals for the worst jobs - especially in the last few years, as millions have fled political and economic woes in countries like Zimbabwe. The global economic downturn has not helped.

Over the last decade, when times turned tough, refugees in towns and cities sometimes became the target of the frustrations of locals. In May 2008, xenophobic violence erupted in Johannesburg and quickly spread to other parts of the country, killing more than 60 people and displacing about 100,000 others.

In Atteridgeville, on the edge of the capital city of Pretoria - and site of some of the worst violence - South African and Somali traders, assisted by UNHCR, negotiated a detailed agreement to settle the original trade dispute that led to the torching of Somali-run shops. The UN refugee agency also supports work by the Nelson Mandela Foundation to counter xenophobia.

South Africa: Searching for Coexistence

Greece: Ramping up refugee receptionPlay video

Greece: Ramping up refugee reception

UNHCR staff are working with Government authorities, NGOs and volunteers on the beaches of the Greek island of Lesvos to receive cold, wet and fearful asylum seekers making landfall around the clock. They wrap them in thermal blankets and take them to warm, safe emergency accommodation at transit sites, with power and Wi-Fi connectivity.
Italy: Mediterranean RescuePlay video

Italy: Mediterranean Rescue

The Italy Navy rescues hundreds of migrants and asylum seekers on the high seas as the numbers of people undertaking the crossing of the Mediterranean from North Africa grows.
Italy: Waiting for AsylumPlay video

Italy: Waiting for Asylum

Sicily has a high number of asylum-seekers because of its location in the south of Italy. In 2011, Cara Mineo was set up to provide asylum-seekers with a place to live while their applications were processed. Today, more than 4,000 people stay there and must wait up to a year for a decision on their applications.