STORIES & INSIGHTS

5 lessons changing how we think about the future

Innovation often aims to solve existing problems. Can learning from unanticipated developments help us challenge assumptions and anticipate future problems?

Kirsten O’Regan, Associate Innovation Officer. Additional reporting by Ana Gray, Stanford in Government Fellow with UNHCR Innovation, and editorial support by Alice Drujon-Candy, Innovation Officer
People carry the roof of a temporary shelter above their heads
UNHCR supports refugees and locals affected by an earthquake in an Ecuadorian city near the Colombian border. Photo: UNHCR/Jaime Giménez

“Before the emergence of generative artificial intelligence, many organizations tended to view AI primarily through a technical lens, as something relevant to data science and specific operational applications,” recalls Nathalie Rami, Deputy Head of Innovation at UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency. “What we underestimated was the speed at which AI would evolve into a technology with implications for almost every aspect of our work. The technology wasn’t new, but the scale and pace of its transformation caught many of us by surprise.” 

 
AI didn’t emerge from the blue. But we, and other humanitarian actors, failed to properly anticipate its impact. And it’s not the only thing we didn’t see coming.   Humanitarian innovation has, arguably, often overemphasized the role of technology while underestimating everything around the tech – trust, maintenance, ownership, and more. It has, sometimes, misread which technologies, and which non-technological elements, would matter most. 

 

Experimentation involves uncertainty: testing unproven approaches is how innovation learns what works and what does not. Systematically applying strategic foresight approaches cannot remove that uncertainty, but it can help organizations decide which assumptions to test, which signals to watch, and where limited resources may have the greatest future value.  

 

Foresight isn’t just about anticipating external trends or disruptions, but also about challenging the assumptions that underpin our strategies, investments, and ways of working. It’s about creating the space to take a step back and see the big picture, from different angles. 

 

Looking back at our experience with innovation, five important lessons stand out. They reveal some of the assumptions that have shaped our decisions. Challenging these assumptions is precisely where strategic foresight can help us make better decisions about the future. 

 

1. The technology was often the easiest part 

For some, innovation is synonymous with technology. But a blinkered focus on deploying the latest gadgets can backfire. “If you make a tech-driven solution, you're often fishing around for a challenge rather than designing something, which might be assisted by a technology, to solve a specific issue,” says Tala Budziszewski, Innovation Officer. “It just ends up being kind of like a technology parachute that nobody really asked for.” 

 

Even when a useful solution is technology assisted, absent a complex ecosystem of trust, infrastructure, regulation, maintenance, access, and institutional integration, that solution – whether it be a connected community centre or an app designed to streamline service delivery – won’t have staying power. In Bangladesh, where broken and old solar-powered appliances had become a huge e-waste problem, one effort to address this ‘ecosystem’ issue has taken off: trained refugee ‘Agents of Change’ are leading efforts to recycle and refurbish devices, extending their lifecycle. 

 

“Working with refugee-led organizations has taught us that technology is often the easiest part,” says Erika Perez, Innovation Officer. “What determines whether something last is much more critical – like, who owns it afterwards, who pays for it, who maintains it, whether communities are trusting it and actually using it, and whether it complements existing systems or mechanisms rather than duplicating them.”  

 

Humanitarian initiatives powered by AI, as by any other technology, will need to pass this test: Is it a solution looking for a challenge? Or is it a forward-thinking response to an existing need? 

 

2. The breakthrough was often already there 

What is innovation, anyway? To many, the word implies a brand-new idea. But some of the most effective innovations come from adapting an existing solution, drawing on local or Indigenous knowledge, or tweaking an established process.  

 

We see this across our portfolio, but one clear example is in the efficacy of nature-based solutions to environmental challenges in displacement settings. “The Earth has evolved a trillion different ways of sustaining life on the planet, involving incredibly complex systems,” says Tala. “Nowadays, people express surprise that, oh, if we apply a nature-based solution, then maybe we can solve a challenge. Well, yeah, this is a solution that has evolved over millions of years.” 

 

In Colombia, for instance, a degraded mangrove ecosystem left refugees and their hosts vulnerable to floods and storms – and the negative health impacts of pollution. A nature-based solution, led by the community, is now restoring the mangroves, while diversifying economic opportunities.

A group of people stand facing the camera, in front of palm trees
In Colombia, a community-based initiative is reviving a precious ecosystem – and supporting those who rely on it. Photo: Guardians of the Mangrove, UNHCR

A key part of innovation is investing time to understand what solutions already exist – and having the humility to recognize when one might serve your purpose. A team working to pre-empt medical stockouts in Tanzania’s Nyarugusu and Nduta refugee camps planned to develop their own predictive modelling solution. Following the Data Innovation Roadmap, which carves out significant space for research and scoping, they discovered ICRC had already developed an open-source pharmacy management tool. Rather than coding from scratch, the team could replicate and adapt. 

 

Critically, novelty is not the same as value. Reinventing the wheel helps no one. Often, “simple things that don’t break” – that have been used before, or are familiar to communities – are, as Tala notes, the ones that can have the biggest impact. 

 

3. A successful pilot wasn't inevitably destined to scale 

For us, innovation doesn’t stop when an idea is proved effective. We innovate to build a better future for and with refugees – and scaling is an essential part of that mission. Yet, widespread integration and adoption of new ideas have proven to be significantly more challenging than invention itself. In part, that’s because good solutions are often locally tailored ones. To reproduce the initial success elsewhere requires adaptation – to different regulatory environments, cultures, capabilities, and operating systems – and a new round of piloting, which can result in a seemingly endless testing stage.

UNHCR’s experience piloting WhatsApp-based communication services across several operations suggests a different pathway. Rather than testing a finished solution in one location and attempting to replicate it later, teams tested the approach across different contexts simultaneously, shared the resulting lessons and prepared the tool for integration into UNHCR’s wider Digital Service. The experience showed that scale depends not only on whether a solution works, but on whether there is an institutional pathway for adopting and sustaining it.

Scale, ultimately, can’t be treated as the final stage of a linear innovation process. It requires its own evidence, partnerships, resources, and institutional decisions. 

 

4. Participation was not the same as ownership  

In the last decade, the humanitarian sector has seen a huge shift from viewing affected communities as passive beneficiaries of aid to active participants in programming. This development has been formalized through commitments to Accountability to Affected Populations (AAP), for instance, and Localization. But participation, it turns out, isn’t enough. Ownership – where communities have the agency, resources, and authority to shape, adapt, and sustain a solution – underpins many successful innovations. 

 

“This probably has been one of the biggest challenges to my own thinking,” says Erika. “Moving from asking, What can we create as UNHCR? Towards, What can we enable?” Communities are experts in their own challenges – and they’re uniquely positioned to deliver effective responses to those challenges. Moreover, as humanitarian funding grows less predictable, we've seen that community ownership can be the difference between a project stalling while awaiting a cash infusion and a project flourishing in times when it is most needed. 

A woman stands, smiling, holding a seedling in each raised hand. Behind her is a background of bright green bushes
In Zimbabwe, young refugee activists are working to address climate change. Photo: UNHCR/Hélène Caux

Of course, communities hold indispensable knowledge, but they can't be expected to possess every technical, policy, financial, or regulatory capability. Equally, technical expertise without lived experience rarely produces trusted, sustainable solutions. Striking a balance – community ownership supported by needed expertise – is key. 

 

In Uganda, for instance, Unidos Social Innovation Centre – the brainchild of Paulinho Muzaliwa, who fled the Democratic Republic of Congo in 2017 – has forged partnerships with UNHCR, permaculture organizations, and Web3 communities to drive forward ambitious, forward-thinking sustainable agriculture projects in response to food insecurity in Nakivale Refugee Settlement. Their approach, which has positively affected more than 5,000 community members, is informed by expertise but premised on local ownership.  

 

“Don’t make the donor the owner of your project,” Paulinho advised recently, at a Refugee-led Innovation skillshare. “Consider the community as your boss, not just your beneficiaries. They are a source of advice and will help you make the right decisions.” In alignment with that approach, Unidos has upskilled more than 3,000 community members – “so the community can continue driving the project and pass the knowledge from generation to generation. This is what we call legacy.”

 

5. We saw many of the signals. We still failed to act. 

The COVID-19 pandemic – and the challenge it posed to humanitarian delivery – was not unimaginable. Political instability and polarization – and their implications for humanitarian funding – did not emerge overnight. AI was not invisible, but the speed and breadth of its adoption were widely underestimated. The real surprise is the gap between seeing change and preparing for it.  

 

Take digital communication with communities, for instance. For years before that WhatsApp solution was piloted, it was clear that this app was a preferred channel for many refugee populations – and that developing a two-way communication solution using it would save people forced to flee and UNHCR significant time, money, and energy. Yet it took necessity – via the emergence of COVID-19 and related physical distancing measures – to catalyze and accelerate dedicated experimentation.  

 

Humanitarian innovation has focused on addressing current problems with new solutions – but it has been less effective at pre-empting emergent challenges. And then there’s the elephant in the room: “Whether earlier Futures and Foresights exercises did or didn't predict what has come to pass, would agencies have been willing to listen?” asks John Warnes, former Innovation Officer. “Would they have been willing to take the hard steps?” 

 

Even when changes are anticipated, systems, incentives, and decision-making processes often prevent organizations from acting on these insights. Foresight only creates value when emerging insights inform leadership decisions, investment choices, and operational planning.

 

Getting better at looking ahead

Foresight is an essential innovation methodology – and a pillar of UN 2.0, which aims to deliver a modernized and effective United Nations system. “The part of foresight is not to predict the next five big things, but to make UNHCR better prepared for several plausible futures,” says Nathalie. “We need to ask not only what crises might occur, but which assumptions do our current delivery model depend upon – and what happens if they suddenly stopped being true.” 

  

The tangible benefits of investing in foresight – and the opportunity cost of not doing so – can be hard to articulate. In an increasingly constrained humanitarian funding environment, this can be a real barrier. Yet economic pressures and the delivery constraints they impose make foresight-informed innovation more essential than ever.  

 

Foresight helps identify emerging challenges, stress-test capabilities, inform decisions about investments, skills, and partnerships, and answer critical questions. How to ensure refugees can access increasingly digitized public infrastructure and services? How best to identify and respond to algorithmic exclusion? What kind of protection risks are climate change-related disasters likely to pose? 

 

For UNHCR, deploying foresight more systematically means bringing emerging signals together with priorities identified by operations and people forced to flee, then using them to inform strategic planning, research questions, and decisions about capabilities, investments, and partnerships. Going forward, foresight practices will be formally integrated across UNHCR Innovation’s programming. 

 

Currently, for instance, we’re working on a suite of briefs for the agency’s leadership on issues we’ve identified as strategically significant for UNHCR’s mandate in the coming years – including, for example, digital employment for refugees. These briefs will bring together macro-predictions for the direction of travel, reflections on what works based on evidence from programming to date, analysis of relevant actors and trends, and recommendations for how UNHCR can position itself in this space. 
 

Of course, foresight only creates value if the organization acts on what it reveals – revisiting assumptions and adapting to emerging realities before disruption makes change unavoidable. 

 

Creating space for the future 

The role of humanitarian innovation is not to generate an endless succession of pilots or predict the next breakthrough technology – it’s to help organizations ask better questions, build evidence, and act on that evidence. 

 

Drawing on lessons from UNHCR North Macedonia’s mainstreaming of foresight, Petar Dimitrov, Associate Innovation Officer, identifies an even more expansive role. “I find the value of foresight not in prediction or contingency planning, which can be done more effectively through big data and predictive analytics, but in its ability to influence how people think about the future,” Petar says. “It creates space to challenge assumptions and have structured conversations about desired futures.” 

 

The five lessons recounted here are part of the evidence base – built across decades of piloting new ideas, conducting research, and working closely with colleagues and communities – that we’ll be using to feed into strategic foresight approaches in the years to come.  

 

How will we know if it’s working? Simply: If the actions we take based on these emerging signals help make desired futures more tangible, driving forward UNHCR’s 50 by 35 vision. Foresight, fundamentally, should help us to proactively build greater inclusion, self-reliance, and durable solutions with and for those forced to flee.