• Text size Normal size text | Increase text size by 10% | Increase text size by 20% | Increase text size by 30%

Proposed revisions could restrict access to Swiss asylum process, warns UNHCR

News Stories, 27 July 2004

© UNHCR/C.Black
Under the new proposals, access to the Swiss asylum system may be restricted for these asylum seekers at a Swiss reception centre.

GENEVA, July 27 (UNHCR) The UN refugee agency has written to the Swiss Federal Office for Refugees to raise concerns about new proposals to modify Swiss asylum law that could restrict access to the asylum process and lead to breaches of the 1951 Refugee Convention.

UNHCR announced on Tuesday that it had submitted to the Swiss authorities comments and suggestions on the new proposals with the aim of contributing positively to the process of drawing up new legislation that both served the interests of Switzerland and safeguarded established international standards designed to protect refugees.

"The proposals appear to be made at a time when the number of asylum seekers has dropped sharply across almost all of Europe, including Switzerland," said the UN agency in a press statement. "There appears to be no need for governments to focus so single-mindedly on restrictive revisions of their asylum laws."

While recognising the need for efficient asylum systems, UNHCR noted that in the Swiss context, efforts to achieve efficiency should not be at the cost of principles of fairness.

"Some of the proposals made by the Federal Office for Refugees are focused on restricting access to the asylum procedure, and this risks running counter to the spirit and the letter of the 1951 Convention," said UNHCR. The agency suggested a number of measures to increase efficiency while ensuring asylum seekers can still gain access to a fair system.

Under the proposed modifications, asylum seekers must submit valid travel or identity documents within 48 hours in order to gain access to a normal asylum procedure. This restriction could lead to breaches of the 1951 Convention.

"Many refugees are not able to obtain national passports or identity papers before fleeing their homeland. If they are being persecuted by the authorities, they cannot go to those same authorities to request the necessary documents," explained UNHCR. "In some countries people may never even have been issued such documents, or they may have been confiscated or destroyed. In other cases, the documents of genuine refugees entering Europe are either stolen or destroyed by the smuggling networks into whose clutches they have fallen."

On the introduction of the concept of humanitarian status, UNHCR has welcomed the move as a way to fill an existing gap in the asylum system. However, the proposed revision recommends granting humanitarian status only to people who can present certain identity documents. This would prevent deserving asylum seekers (including people fleeing war or generalised violence) who do not fall under the strict definition of the 1951 UN Convention from receiving adequate international protection.

"UNHCR fully recognises the principle that asylum seekers should cooperate with the authorities in the host country, as mentioned in Article 31 of the 1951 UN Convention," said the statement. "They should, however, be afforded an opportunity to have their claim heard. A lack of documentation could under certain circumstances call into question the credibility of the asylum seeker, when examining the claim on its merits."

Another point of contention is a proposal to share data with the asylum seeker's country of origin after a first instance decision. According to UNHCR, such information-sharing should only be permitted when it is definitively determined that a person does not have a genuine fear of persecution in his or her country of origin in other words after the completion of the asylum procedure, including appeals. Otherwise, there is an increased possibility that the asylum seeker or family members could be put at risk.

At the regional level, "the challenges to migration and asylum systems in Europe are multi-faceted and will require a global approach over the coming years. They cannot be resolved in isolation," said the UN agency, noting that more resources must be allocated to crisis areas, either to prevent fledgling conflicts spinning out of control, or to provide support to major refugee-hosting countries in the region.

The agency also stressed that more attention needs to be paid to establishing regular migration channels that would undercut the existing smuggling networks.




UNHCR country pages


Advocacy is a key element in UNHCR activities to protect people of concern.


UNHCR advocates fair and efficient procedures for asylum-seekers

Zero-Star "Hotel" that Asylum-Seekers Call Home in Dijon

France is one of the main destinations for asylum-seekers in Europe, with some 55,000 new asylum applications in 2012. As a result of the growing number of applicants, many French cities are facing an acute shortage of accommodation for asylum-seekers.

The government is trying to address the problem and, in February 2013, announced the creation of 4,000 additional places in state-run reception centres for asylum-seekers. But many asylum-seekers are still forced to sleep rough or to occupy empty buildings. One such building, dubbed the "Refugee Hotel" by its transient population, lies on the outskirts of the eastern city of Dijon. It illustrates the critical accommodation situation.

The former meat-packing plant is home to about 100 asylum-seekers, mostly from Chad, Mali and Somalia, but also from Georgia, Kosovo and other Eastern European countries. Most are single men, but there are also two families.

In this dank, rat-infested empty building, the pipes leak and the electricity supply is sporadic. There is only one lavatory, two taps with running water, no bathing facilities and no kitchen. The asylum-seekers sleep in the former cold-storage rooms. The authorities have tried to close the squat several times. These images, taken by British photographer Jason Tanner, show the desperate state of the building and depict the people who call it home.

Zero-Star "Hotel" that Asylum-Seekers Call Home in Dijon

2013 UNHCR Nansen Refugee Award

UN High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres presented Sister Angélique Namaika of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) with the prestigious Nansen Refugee Award at a gala ceremony in Geneva on Monday night.

Sister Angélique, through her Centre for Reintegration and Development, has helped transform the lives of more than 2,000 women and girls who had been forced from their homes and abused by fighters of the Lord's Resistance Army (LRA) or other armed groups. Many of those she helps suffered abduction, forced labour, beatings, murder, rape or other human rights abuses.

The Roman Catholic nun helps survivors to heal by offering them the chance to learn a trade, start a small business or go to school. Testimonies from these women show the remarkable effect she has had on helping turn around their lives, with many affectionately calling her "mother."

The Award ceremony featured a keynote speech from best-selling author Paulo Coelho and musical performances by singer-songwriter Dido, Malaysian singer-songwriter Yuna and Grammy-nominated Malian musicians, Amadou and Mariam.

2013 UNHCR Nansen Refugee Award

Nansen Refugee Award Presentation Ceremony

More than 400 people attended the annual presentation in Geneva in October 1, 2012 of UNHCR's Nansen Refugee Award. This year's inspirational winner from Somalia, Hawa Aden Mohamed, was unable to attend for health reasons, but she sent a video message. In the former refugee's absence, UN High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres presented the award and Nansen medal to her sister, Shukri Aden Mohamed.

The 63-year-old humanitarian, educator and women's rights advocate, widely known as "Mama" Hawa, was honoured for her extraordinary service - under extremely difficult conditions - on behalf of refugees and the internally displaced, mainly women and girls but also including boys.

Above all she has been recognized for her work - as founder and director of the Galkayo Education Centre for Peace and Development in Somalia's Puntland region - in helping to empower thousands of displaced Somali women and girls, many of whom are victims of rape. The centre provides secondary education as well as life skills training.

The packed event also included an address by Liberian peace activist Leymah Gbowee, co-winner of last year's Nobel Peace Prize, and a video tribute to Mama Hawa as well as performances from UNHCR Honorary Lifetime Goodwill Ambassador and classical singer, Barbara Hendricks, and up and coming Swiss musician Bastian Baker.

Nansen Refugee Award Presentation Ceremony

Greece: Ramping up refugee receptionPlay video

Greece: Ramping up refugee reception

UNHCR staff are working with Government authorities, NGOs and volunteers on the beaches of the Greek island of Lesvos to receive cold, wet and fearful asylum seekers making landfall around the clock. They wrap them in thermal blankets and take them to warm, safe emergency accommodation at transit sites, with power and Wi-Fi connectivity.
Switzerland: Kuwait Donates US$ 100 Million to the Syria CrisisPlay video

Switzerland: Kuwait Donates US$ 100 Million to the Syria Crisis

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees welcomes the State of Kuwait's contribution of US$ 100 million to support UNHCR operations aiding Syrians.
Italy: Mediterranean RescuePlay video

Italy: Mediterranean Rescue

The Italy Navy rescues hundreds of migrants and asylum seekers on the high seas as the numbers of people undertaking the crossing of the Mediterranean from North Africa grows.