Integration systems in Central Europe at breaking point

News Stories, 8 July 2009

© UNHCR/B.Szandelszky
Worried about the Future: A refugee in Slovakia ponders his situation in Central Europe.

BUDAPEST, Hungary, July 8 (UNHCR) Louis* works a 14-hour day in his small fast-food shop in Budapest, but the Iraqi refugee is still struggling to feed his family and pay his rent. Many others like him are also having a hard time in Central European countries, where integration systems are either non-existent or poorly developed.

"I am not lazy," says the 46-year-old, who really wants to make a success of his new life in Hungary with his wife Anna* and their two children aged 11 and 13 years. The Christian family fled Iraq in 2006 to escape sectarian violence and were granted asylum in Hungary six months later.

This gave them legal status, but also meant they would quickly have to become self-sufficient. That's because Hungary, like other Central European countries that have joined the European Union in the past five years, for a long time regarded itself simply as a transit country for refugees.

These countries failed to implement integration systems and policies and, as a result, the growing numbers of refugees and asylum seekers deciding to settle in Central Europe found themselves without any safety nets. They received no integration support from the government in areas such as language, employment, accommodation or vocational training.

Areti Sianni, an expert on integration working with UNHCR in Budapest, said some efforts had been made to improve the situation in recent years, but she added that these "modest gains are now at serious risk at a time of economic crisis, when governments are tempted to introduce budget cuts to already under-funded integration services. The system is at breaking point."

Louis runs his little food shop out of necessity rather than love. He is a specialist in agricultural engineering, but is unable to find a job in this field despite taking a six-month Hungarian language course. "I have a university degree which I will never use," he lamented.

He set up the fast-food business with the help of a church organization, but the income is not enough to cover all the family bills. "Here I work, but I do not earn," he said, while adding that Anna is studying to become a kindergarten teacher so that they could make a bit more money. But she won't graduate for another year.

Sianni sympathizes with people like Louis and Anna. "Integration systems in this part of Europe have proven less than effective in helping people to become independent and integrate into local communities," she said, adding that integration services and support should be provided at the community level until the refugees were "ready for independent and dignified living on a par with citizens."

Integration is a complex endeavour, involving many different stakeholders, but Sianni said that her year-long research into the situation in Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia had found that these countries lacked the elements needed to ensure a life of dignity for refugees.

She said that after going through short and patchy integration programmes, many people are left to their own devices without possessing the skills to make a living. In some cases, people spend 90 percent of their income on accommodation. Many end up living in poverty, Sianni said, adding that they were marginalized, excluded and at risk of homelessness.

UNHCR, meanwhile, has developed and distributed guidelines on refugee integration aimed at helping governments tackle the problem. But the refugee agency fears that the current economic crisis could tempt Central European countries to cut their integration programmes in a bid to save money.

Sianni thinks this is short-sighted. "Well-integrated refugees are economically independent. They earn money and pay taxes. Refugees who do not receive the necessary assistance to integrate are especially vulnerable as they do not even have social networks to catch them. They become a burden rather than net contributors to society," she said.

Louis, meanwhile, fears about the future after deciding to close his business because he can't afford the rent anymore. "I do not want a car or property, just a life," he said.

* Names changed for protection reasons

By Melita H. Sunjic in Budapest, Hungary




UNHCR country pages

UNHCR Guidelines on Refugee Integration in Central Europe

Read the refugee integration guidelines on UNHCR's Regional Representation for Central Europe website.

Local Integration

Integration of refugees in the host community allows recipients to live in dignity and peace.

Integration Initiatives: Supporting Next Steps

An inventory of opportunities and needs in the integration of resettled refugees

Looking Back: When Hungary's Borders with Austria Opened for East Germans

It's not often that a single sentence can send a photographer rushing into action, but Hungarian photographer Barnabas Szabo did not have to hear more than that of then-Hungarian Foreign Minister Guyla Horn's televised announcement 25 years ago - September 10, 1989 - that at midnight Hungary would open its border with Austria and let East German refugees leave the country. "After the very first sentence I jumped up, took my camera, ran to my old Trabant and set off for the border," he recalled. The effect of Hungary's momentous decision was freedom for tens of thousands of East Germans who had been streaming into Hungary since May. At first they found refuge in the West German embassy, but as numbers grew, refugee camps were set up in Budapest and on the shores of Lake Balaton. The collapse of the Berlin Wall followed less than two months later. Communism was swept from Eastern Europe by the end of 1989. Another Hungarian photographer, Tamas Szigeti, who visited the abandoned refugee camp at Csilleberc the following day, recorded the haste in which people departed, leaving clothes, toys and even half-cooked dinners. No matter how uncertain the new life beckoning to them, the East Germans were clearly ready to leave fear and the Communist dictatorship behind forever.

Looking Back: When Hungary's Borders with Austria Opened for East Germans

Hungarian Crisis - 50th Anniversary

The spontaneous Hungarian uprising began on 23 October 1956. Two weeks later, the revolution was crushed by a Soviet military intervention, and by early 1957, 200,000 people had fled as refugees - 180,000 to Austria and 20,000 to Yugoslavia.

Hundreds of volunteers worked alongside international and local aid organizations to provide shelter and food, as the Austrians and the international community provided the refugees with an unprecedented level of support.

UNHCR was made 'Lead Agency' and, along with the Red Cross and ICEM, helped coordinate protection, assistance and a quite extraordinary resettlement programme.

Within two years, more than 180,000 Hungarians were resettled to 37 countries spanning five continents. The US, Canada, the UK, West Germany, Australia, Switzerland, France, Sweden and Belgium each accepted more than 5,000 refugees. Italy, the Netherlands, Israel, Brazil, Norway, Denmark, South Africa, New Zealand and Argentina all took over 1,000. The rest were spread around a further 19 countries ranging from the Dominican Republic to Turkey. Some Hungarians were integrated in Austria (8,000) and Yugoslavia (700), while 11,000 returned home voluntarily.

More in Refugees Magazine Issue N° 144: Where Are They Now? The Hungarian Refugees, 50 Years On (published October 2006) here

Hungarian Crisis - 50th Anniversary

Iraqi Children Go To School in Syria

UNHCR aims to help 25,000 refugee children go to school in Syria by providing financial assistance to families and donating school uniforms and supplies.

There are some 1.4 million Iraqi refugees living in Syria, most having fled the extreme sectarian violence sparked by the bombing of the Golden Mosque of Samarra in 2006.

Many Iraqi refugee parents regard education as a top priority, equal in importance to security. While in Iraq, violence and displacement made it difficult for refugee children to attend school with any regularity and many fell behind. Although education is free in Syria, fees associated with uniforms, supplies and transportation make attending school impossible. And far too many refugee children have to work to support their families instead of attending school.

To encourage poor Iraqi families to register their children, UNHCR plans to provide financial assistance to at least 25,000 school-age children, and to provide uniforms, books and school supplies to Iraqi refugees registered with UNHCR. The agency will also advise refugees of their right to send their children to school, and will support NGO programmes for working children.

UNHCR's ninemillion campaign aims to provide a healthy and safe learning environment for nine million refugee children by 2010.

Iraqi Children Go To School in Syria

Hungary: Beginning to HelpPlay video

Hungary: Beginning to Help

Refugees and migrants continue to arrive from Serbia into Hungary in by the thousands. But now, thanks to requests from the Hungarian government,UNHCR is helping in bringing order and more speed to dealing with the newcomers.
Hungary: Stranded in BudapestPlay video

Hungary: Stranded in Budapest

Outside the Keleti train station in Budapest, over 3,000 refugees wait to continue their journey. For two days now, they have been stuck here after Hungarian authorities closed off the station, preventing all refugees from taking trains bound for Austria and Germany.
Too Much Pain: The Voices of Refugee Women, part 1/6Play video

Too Much Pain: The Voices of Refugee Women, part 1/6

Stories of refugee women who have undergone Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) and are engaged to end this practice. These women explain their experiences of flight, asylum and integration in the EU.